Jump to content

Interesting article on being insured but paying cash

Recommended Posts

Even if you have health insurance, you may want to pay cash



More relevant part:


Five blood tests were performed in March at Torrance Memorial Medical Center. The hospital charged the patients insurer, Blue Shield of California, $408. The patient was responsible for paying $269.42.


If that were all there was to this -- which its not -- youd be justified in shaking your head and wondering how it could cost more than $80 apiece for blood tests. These werent exotic procedures. The tests were for fairly common things such as levels of vitamins D and B12 in the blood.


Its what happened next, though, that this makes this story particularly interesting.


The patient, who for privacy reasons requested that I use only her first name, Caroline, was curious about why she needed to pay almost $300 for a handful of routine tests. So she called the hospital.


I was completely surprised, Caroline told me. The woman I spoke with in billing said that if Id paid cash, the prices would have been much lower.


How much lower? Try this on for size: Tests that were billed to Blue Shield at a rate of about $80 each carried a cash price of closer to $15 apiece.


It absolutely makes sense to shop around for healthcare like you shop for everything else. Glenn Melnick, health economist at USC


I found that hard to believe so I got in touch with Torrance Memorial Medical Center. A spokeswoman, Ann OBrien, didnt want to delve into hospital pricing but acknowledged that, yes, the cash prices quoted to Caroline were accurate.


This is utterly crazy, Caroline said. Its such a huge difference. Why wouldnt I just always tell them that I want to pay cash?


Great question. And answering that highlights the insanity of U.S. healthcare pricing.


This is one of the dirty little secrets of healthcare, said Gerald Kominski, director of the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research. If your insurance has a high deductible, you should always ask the cash price.


Cash prices are intended for uninsured patients -- and are frequently still much higher than insured rates. But cash prices for many common procedures have come down thanks to changing regulations and consumers increasingly being able to shop around for cheaper providers.





Getting ready to join the RV full-time lifestyle in 2017!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very interesting, indeed! I wonder if an insurance company could somehow work it so that the insured appears to pay the medical facility in cash, but yet be the money behind the process. That could save some money and lower premiums......

Good travelin !...............Kirk

Full-time 11+ years...... Now seasonal travelers.
Kirk & Pam's Great RV Adventure



Link to comment
Share on other sites

The discount for cash payment varies a lot from my experience. My insurance doesn't pay for a physical so I asked about a cash payment discount. Sure they told me but the discounted price was more than the insurance negotiated cost. By letting it go through insurance first the final bill was $10 less than the cash discount.


2001 Volvo VNL 42 Cummins ISX Autoshift

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've also tried to pay in cash and found that the price was higher. But like any negotiation you may find lower prices....it just "depends".

Jack & Danielle Mayer #60376 Lifetime Member
Living on the road since 2000

PLEASE no PM's. Email me. jackdanmayer AT gmail
2016 DRV Houston 44' 5er (we still have it)
2022 New Horizons 43' 5er
2016 Itasca 27N 28' motorhome 
2019 Volvo 860, D13 455/1850, 236" wb, I-Shift, battery-based APU
No truck at the moment - we use one of our demo units
2016 smart Passion, piggyback on the truck
See our website for info on New Horizons 5th wheels, HDTs as tow vehicles, communications on the road, and use of solar power
Principal in RVH Lifestyles. RVH-Lifestyles.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A couple of things caught my attention about this story. First, the tests were performed at a Hospital. I think it is pretty well known that everything costs more at a hospital, so comparing their charge to say Labcorp is interesting but I am not sure very relevant. This very issue was one of the big selling points of the Affordable Care Act which was supposed to reduce costs by getting fewer people to use the hospital emergency room for routine care that could be obtained outside the hospital at a lower cost.


Second, they used the term "billing". I get statements from BCBS all the time. What the doctor bills and what BCBS pays are often two different things. On my last doctor's visit BCBS was billed $160. BCBS paid $88. Because the doctor was an in network provider, they accepted the BCBS payment and I paid nothing. If the doctor did not accept the BCBS payment as payment in full then I would likely have to pay the difference or try to negotiate.

The one that dies with the most toys is still dead!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Had a male friend a number of years ago who developed breast cancer. He did not have health insurance. The surgeon's price with insurance was a lot more than the cash price he obtained. He was able to negotiate a discount with the hospital for paying cash.


We have negotiated a discounted cash price with the hospital in past years as we had a high deductible HSA, therefore were paying a lot out of pocket. In 2014, and prior to Medicare, we once again asked for a discounted cash price with the hospital and were told they don't do that anymore.

Gene, Gayle, & Oliver-(the dog)
2006 Holiday Rambler Endeavor 40 PDQ
2012 Honda CRV toad
Blue Ox tow bar & base plate/Air Force One braking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have blood work done at least two times a year. I can use Labcorp or Quest

for the blood work and I have never paid anything! No twenty percent co-pay.

How is that not better then a cash discount?

When I had a pacemaker put in 2008 the hospital billed $96,000 for the pacemaker and five days in the hospital.

The insurance company because of their discount paid $56,000. Do you think that I could get a lower price by paying cash?

I wouldn't have the $56,000 to pay cash!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That is interesting, we all now have to have health insurance and there are clinics that don't take insurance?

I will not be going to those clinics! Paying cash may be alright if it doesn't cost much. But I repeat: how woiuld you pay cash for a pacemake?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The hoops and regulatory paperwork is not allowing MDs to spend the time they would like to with their patients. So they offer services to their patients at a discounted rate for cash. You can submit paperwork to the insurance company on your own behalf to keep track of the deductible but many of us never reach our deductible

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You may have insurance but what is your deductible and then your copy? When I owned my own clinic I would much rather receive cash. My wife did my billing and we were routinely denied payment by insurance until she would call and they would pay. It is really irritating that they would deny just to try to save money, not because it wasn't a legitimate claim.

Ron C.

2013 Dynamax Trilogy 3850 D3

2000 Kenworth T2000 Optimus Prime

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here are some articles




http://www.wausaudailyherald.com/story/life/2016/05/26/get-more-1--1-time-your-doctor/84789402/May 26, 2016 ...Concierge medicine is a membership-based personalized care program where patients have direct access to their physician, spend a great ...


A friend is Wausau got letter from her MD a couple of years ago that he is offering this service.



The Doctor Will See You but Not Your Insurance Direct primary care physicians expect to be paid by you — directly

by Sid Kirchheimer, August 6, 2013



Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

RVers Online University



RV Destinations

Find out more or sign up for Escapees RV'ers Bootcamp.

Advertise your product or service here.

RVTravel.com Logo

  • Create New...