I agree with all of your comments. My Flex Armor roof was installed in January 2016 and it still looks just like it did 5 years ago. During a major storm at my home base this past October a 6 inch diameter tree limb from a close by 150 year old oak tree fell from 45' or so. It was a glancing blow right to the corner of my roof and the only damage was an area of bark residue from the limb which wiped off with a damp cloth. No damage, no dents, no tear and best of all no leaks or caulking to worry about. Mine was installed in Madison, AL.